← All comparisons About this coin → Back to Stakr
StakrBullion Comparison


American Gold Buffalo 1oz

Best Price on American Gold Buffalo 1oz — Live Dealer Comparison

🇺🇸 USA · Spot $4,187.76 · 8 dealers compared · prices refreshed hourly during market hours

Cheapest right now
$4,386.06
at SD Bullion · +$198.31 (4.7%)
View at SD Bullion →
➕ Add this to my Stakr

American Gold Buffalo 1oz premium history

Premium tracking started 2026-07-05 — the chart builds daily as we record dealer prices.

Sort by
DealerTotal (USD)PremiumVerified
🇺🇸SD Bullion
★★★★☆ 4.0 (3k · Trustpilot)
$4,386.06 +$198.31 (4.7%) 16 min ago View →
🇨🇦Border Gold
★★★★☆ 4.6 (179 · Trustpilot)
$4,412.28(CAD 6268.31) +$224.53 (5.4%) 16 min ago View →
🇺🇸Money Metals Exchange
★★★☆☆ 2.8 (203 · Trustpilot)
$4,543.10 +$355.35 (8.5%) 16 min ago View →
🇺🇸JM Bullion
★★★★☆ 4.1 (2.1k · Trustpilot)
$4,558.09 +$370.34 (8.8%) 5d ago stale View →
🇺🇸APMEX
★★★★☆ 4.1 (8.8k · Trustpilot)
$4,709.16 +$521.40 (12.5%) 16 min ago View →
🇨🇦Global Bullion Suppliers
★★★★★ 4.9 (201 · Trustpilot)
$4,272.64(CAD 6069.93) +$84.89 (2.0%) Out of stock View →
🇨🇦Silver Gold Bull
★★★★☆ 4.5 (4.9k · Trustpilot)
$4,320.71(CAD 6138.22) +$132.96 (3.2%) Out of stock View →
🇨🇦Canadian PMX
★★★☆☆ 3.7 (1 · Trustpilot)
$4,334.32(CAD 6157.55) +$146.56 (3.5%) Out of stock View →

What to look for when buying American Gold Buffalo 1oz

Total cost = spot price + dealer premium. Premiums vary by dealer, payment method, and quantity. Most dealers offer a discount for cash/check/wire vs credit card (3–4%). Stock fluctuates; out-of-stock dealers are sorted to the bottom.

Why premiums vary

Each dealer balances inventory cost, hedging strategy, and target customer base differently. Low-volume specialty dealers may charge more for service; high-volume dealers compete on margin. Premiums also rise during physical shortages.

Track every coin you buy

Stakr is a free portfolio tracker for gold and silver investors. Log each purchase with date and cost, set price alerts, and see your average cost vs current spot.

Start tracking — it's free

More comparisons

Prices scraped from each dealer's public product pages hourly during US market hours. Stakr does not earn affiliate commissions on these links.